Public sources checked on . Every loan rate, cost and result in the worked example is hypothetical.

How do you calculate refinancing break-even? Compare cumulative interest on two repayment schedules using the same opening balance and remaining tenure, then subtract the net cost of switching. Also calculate when lower instalments recover the upfront cost: that is a different measure. In the illustration below, interest-cost break-even is month 11, while instalment-payment recovery is month 17.

This article works through one calculation. For the wider process, see our home loan refinancing overview. For the choice between banks, see repricing versus refinancing.

Start both loans from the same position

Imagine a fully disbursed mortgage with S$600,000 outstanding and exactly 20 years left. Compare keeping it at an assumed 3.50% a year with refinancing the same S$600,000 over the same 240 months at an assumed 2.80% a year. These are invented inputs, not advertised rates or an available bank offer.

Hypothetical comparison assumptions
Input Keep existing loan Refinance
Starting principal S$600,000 S$600,000
Remaining tenure 240 months 240 months
Annual nominal interest rate 3.50% 2.80%
Payment timing End of each month End of each month
Rate path in base case Unchanged Unchanged
Fees added to mortgage None None; switching costs paid separately

There is no cash-out, tenure extension, payment holiday or additional repayment. Interest uses a simplified monthly-rest model: annual nominal rate divided by 12. All calculations retain unrounded values internally; displayed amounts are rounded to cents. A lender’s actual interest convention, payment dates and rounding can produce different figures.

MoneySense explains monthly-rest interest and the importance of comparing repayment schedules. Our figures below are independently calculated, rather than taken from its examples.

Put the switching costs on a separate line

The following amounts are invented for this exercise. They are not a market fee range, a bank tariff or confirmation that a subsidy is available. Treat the assumed costs as final payable totals, including any applicable tax.

Hypothetical completion-date cost ledger
Item Amount Treatment
Legal and conveyancing cost S$2,500 Cost
Valuation cost S$300 Cost
Administrative and discharge costs S$200 Cost
Repayment of an existing subsidy S$1,500 Cost
Existing lock-in penalty S$0 Assumed not payable
Interest in lieu of insufficient notice S$0 Assumed not payable
New subsidy -S$1,000 Assumed received at completion and retained
Net switching cost, C S$3,500 Paid outside the mortgage

C = S$2,500 + S$300 + S$200 + S$1,500 – S$1,000 = S$3,500.

For this base case, assume there is no further difference in exit charges between the two routes at the comparison date. Real packages may not satisfy that assumption. If a new subsidy is paid later, keep the full initial funding requirement in the cash-flow schedule until receipt. If it is clawed back, add the repayment at the date it becomes payable.

DBS’s published fee schedule illustrates why lock-in status and legal or valuation costs need checking. The binding cost for your case comes from the applicable offer, terms and redemption quotation, not our invented ledger.

Calculate the instalment and each month’s interest

For a level-payment amortising loan, use:

A = P x r / [1 - (1 + r)^(-n)]
Monthly interest I(t) = B(t-1) x r
Principal repaid Q(t) = A - I(t)
Closing principal B(t) = B(t-1) - Q(t)

P is opening principal, r is the annual nominal rate divided by 12, n is the number of remaining monthly payments, A is the instalment, and B(0) = P. If r is zero, A = P / n.

The existing loan’s monthly instalment is S$3,479.76. The proposed loan’s is S$3,267.83. The reduction is S$211.92 a month, calculated before display rounding.

In month 1, existing-loan interest is S$600,000 x 0.035 / 12 = S$1,750.00. Proposed-loan interest is S$600,000 x 0.028 / 12 = S$1,400.00. Principal repaid is S$1,729.76 versus S$1,867.83. The S$350.00 interest difference therefore appears partly as a lower payment and partly as faster principal repayment.

First 12 months: hypothetical monthly interest and closing principal, all amounts in S$
Month Existing interest Proposed interest Existing closing principal Proposed closing principal Cumulative interest saved, before fees
1 1,750.00 1,400.00 598,270.24 598,132.17 350.00
2 1,744.95 1,395.64 596,535.44 596,259.97 699.31
3 1,739.90 1,391.27 594,795.57 594,383.41 1,047.93
4 1,734.82 1,386.89 593,050.64 592,502.47 1,395.86
5 1,729.73 1,382.51 591,300.61 590,617.14 1,743.09
6 1,724.63 1,378.11 589,545.48 588,727.41 2,089.61
7 1,719.51 1,373.70 587,785.23 586,833.27 2,435.42
8 1,714.37 1,369.28 586,019.84 584,934.72 2,780.51
9 1,709.22 1,364.85 584,249.31 583,031.73 3,124.89
10 1,704.06 1,360.41 582,473.61 581,124.30 3,468.54
11 1,698.88 1,355.96 580,692.73 579,212.42 3,811.47
12 1,693.69 1,351.50 578,906.66 577,296.08 4,153.66

Keep three different results separate

After 12 payments, the proposed loan has produced:

  • S$2,543.08 less in cumulative instalments. This is reduced loan-payment outflow, which may be funded from cash, CPF or a combination; it is not automatically extra cash in a bank account.
  • S$1,610.58 less remaining principal. The proposed balance is S$577,296.08, compared with S$578,906.66. This is a debt reduction advantage, not spendable cash.
  • S$4,153.66 less cumulative interest. The payment reduction plus the principal difference equals the interest saving. Do not count the principal advantage again on top of interest savings.
Interest saving through month h
= cumulative existing interest - cumulative proposed interest
= cumulative instalment reduction + existing balance - proposed balance

Net interest-cost benefit at h
= interest saving - net switching cost
  - any additional net cost of exiting the proposed route at h

With no additional exit-cost difference assumed, the 12-month net interest-cost benefit is S$4,153.66 – S$3,500 = S$653.66. Yet cumulative lower instalments minus the upfront cost remain negative S$956.92. Both statements are true: some benefit sits in lower debt.

Find both break-even dates

Interest-cost break-even is the first month in which cumulative interest savings cover S$3,500. At month 10, savings are S$3,468.54, leaving a S$31.46 shortfall. At month 11, they reach S$3,811.47. The base-case answer is therefore month 11.

Instalment-payment recovery asks when lower payments alone recover the separately paid cost. With constant payments, use C / (A_existing – A_proposed), rounded up to the next whole payment month. Here it is month 17: month 16 remains S$109.23 short, while month 17 is S$102.70 ahead.

Neither date is a recommendation to refinance. This is an undiscounted comparison: it excludes the return forgone on upfront money, CPF opportunity costs, insurance differences and other household effects. Add relevant differences before making a personal decision. If fees are financed, increase the proposed principal and recalculate rather than keeping this same-balance result.

Two different break-even measures

Hypothetical S$600,000 loans, 240 months, constant 3.50% versus 2.80%, S$3,500 switching cost paid separately. Both lines subtract that cost.

Interest-cost benefit crosses zero at month 11; payment recovery at month 17The solid blue line measures cumulative interest saving less costs. The dashed charcoal line measures cumulative instalment reduction less costs. At month24 they reach S$4,701.02 and S$1,586.16 respectively. Selected exact values are in the following table.S$5,000S$0−S$3,50001224Months after switching

Solid blue: net interest-cost benefit. Dashed charcoal: net instalment-payment recovery. Lines connect monthly calculation points.

Selected exact chart values, in S$
Month Net interest benefit Net payment recovery
0 −3,500.00 −3,500.00
10 −31.46 −1,380.77
11 311.47 −1,168.84
12 653.66 −956.92
16 2,015.00 −109.23
17 2,353.45 102.70
24 4,701.02 1,586.16

Source: SHS calculations using the assumptions and amortisation method stated above; independently recalculated 8 November 2026. No forecast, bank quote or guaranteed saving. Some benefit is lower debt rather than spendable cash.

Test a smaller rate advantage and a higher fee

Each row below is a separate hypothetical constant-rate scenario, with the existing loan still at 3.50%, both opening balances S$600,000, both tenures 240 months, and C still S$3,500. None is a current-rate claim.

Hypothetical sensitivity over 24 months
Proposed annual rate Proposed monthly instalment 24-month interest saving less S$3,500 First interest-cost break-even month
2.50% S$3,179.42 S$8,203.85 8
2.80% S$3,267.83 S$4,701.02 11
3.20% S$3,387.98 S$19.35 24
3.50% S$3,479.76 -S$3,500.00 No break-even
4.00% S$3,635.88 -S$9,380.25 No break-even

At the base rates, removing the assumed S$1,000 subsidy raises C to S$4,500 and moves interest-cost break-even to month 14. Adding a hypothetical S$9,000 early-exit penalty to the original ledger raises C to S$12,500 and moves it to month 38, beyond a two-year comparison. These fee scenarios do not represent any lender’s quotation.

A rate reset can reverse an early benefit

Suppose the proposed rate is 2.80% for the first 12 payments, then rises to a hypothetical 4.00% for months 13-24. Re-amortise the actual month-12 proposed balance of S$577,296.08 over the remaining 228 months. The new monthly instalment is S$3,618.90. Keep the existing route at the assumed 3.50% throughout.

By month 24, interest savings less the S$3,500 cost become negative S$2,147.67. The earlier month-11 crossing did not guarantee a lasting benefit. A real floating package needs a month-by-month rate path, reset dates, benchmark plus spread, and the bank’s payment-adjustment method. Recalculate both routes when either rate changes.

Check the contract dates before using the result

Ask the current bank for a dated redemption quotation and check the lock-in end date, notice requirements and subsidy-clawback expiry separately. Confirm when a new lock-in begins and the cost of selling, refinancing or making a partial repayment during it. Do not assume the end of a fixed-rate period is also the end of every restriction.

MoneySense recommends comparing staying, repricing and refinancing, including repayment schedules and relevant penalties. Request a written same-bank alternative and run it through the same calculation. Compare complete terms using our bank home-loan comparison guide.

For an HDB flat, check the applicable financing route separately. MoneySense notes that a bank-financed HDB mortgage cannot be refinanced back to an HDB housing loan. Use HDB’s financial-institution housing-loan guidance for the relevant official route.

If CPF is involved, the arithmetic does not complete the administrative switch. CPF Board explains the lawyer-authorised refinancing application and states that the current CPF instalment payment to the existing financier ceases upon approval of that application. Confirm the new arrangements and any applicable HPS requirements with the bank, lawyer and CPF Board.

Frequently asked questions

Can I divide fees by the monthly instalment reduction?

Yes, for a simplified payment-recovery measure with constant payments and an upfront cost. It does not measure interest savings accurately on its own because remaining principal can differ. If payments or costs change over time, use cumulative cash flows instead.

Does a lower monthly payment prove refinancing is cheaper?

No. A longer tenure can lower the payment while leaving more debt outstanding. Hold the starting balance and tenure constant first, then examine costs, interest and closing principal over your chosen horizon.

Is there one acceptable break-even period for everyone?

No. The useful horizon depends on your plans and the written restrictions. A planned sale, rate reset or new clawback can change the comparison before or after the first break-even month.

Discuss the comparison without sending sensitive documents

Start with the property type, an approximate outstanding balance, remaining tenure and relevant dates if known. The initial SHS enquiry should not contain NRIC images or numbers, Singpass credentials, bank statements or other sensitive documents. Provide any bank-required documents only through the chosen bank’s secure, independently verified channel.

SHS provides mortgage comparison support. This article is general educational information, not personalised financial advice or a lending offer. The lender determines pricing, eligibility and approval. Read about SHS and its role or return to the refinancing overview.

Sources and calculation date

Public sources checked on 1 November 2026. The example, sensitivity tests and tables are SHS calculations using the stated hypothetical assumptions.

  1. MoneySense: How home loans work. Page displays last updated 28 September 2026. Used for monthly-rest context, comparison steps, loan terms and the bank-to-HDB restriction.
  2. DBS: Home Loan Fees and Charges. No reliable page-update date observed. Used for fee categories, not the example’s amounts.
  3. HDB: Housing Loan from Financial Institutions. No reliable page-update date observed. Used as the official financing-route reference, not a source for our hypothetical costs.
  4. CPF Board: What should I do to refinance the housing loan for my property? Page displays last updated 29 January 2026. Used for CPF application and payment arrangements.